Napoleonic Wargame Club (NWC)

Does anyone actually play the HPS games in multiphase mode? If so, do you feel that there would be any advantage in restoring the apparently (is it still lurking in the code but just deactivated?) defunct charge phase from the BG games and also the possibility of changing formation, forming square and cavalry counter-charging in the defensive phase?

Also, are there people out there who still mainly play the BG games and are reluctant to play the HPS games on account of the above reason (ie. the loss of these BG features from the HPS multiphase engine). Would incorporating these features make any difference?

Capt Rich White
4th Cavalry Brigade
Cavalry Corps
Anglo-Allied Army