Quaama wrote:
Thank-you very much for running the Tournament. I found it very enjoyable and I know some opponents also enjoyed the scenarios whether they won or lost.
Thanks for the kind words, Paul!
I did try hard to choose quality scenarios where both sides had a chance.
I was surprised by Scenario #1's lopsided results as well. On paper it looked very even but the Johnny Rebs must have really wanted to regain the Kentucky bluegrass.
I was also surprised Scenario #4 was a comfortable Union victory as I viewed it as a more even matchup or one that favored the Rebs.
Interesting that the Rebs lost both Shiloh matches against Grant's men but beat up on Buell in the Chickamauga games.
The (real) Union Army of the Tennessee saved the tournament for the Federals.