nelmsm wrote:
Cruces wrote:
Would you think a Mexican War Variant for the the Club might be valuable?
MG Elkin
XVIth Corp-Commander
AotT
As to the Mexican War variant I do believe that the Cabinet discussed adding Mexican War to our line up but in the end it was decided to leave it with the Colonial Campaign Club as it was part of the Early American War series.
General Nelms,
Since the format allows for questions from opponents I would like to asks the following questions.
MG Elkin asked you a question and you answered that it was discussed and not accepted because it was in another club. The response does not tell us what you think and is too general, what is your position?
I put forward the request to include this game in the ACWGC. I would ask that you clarify your answer and give your personal view. Just because a game is on another club why would not make it worthwhile to be included in the ACWGC? Every other title that our club supports is available in other clubs. If that is the answer then why do we have an ACWGC? You can play all the games at the Blitzkrieg club? The Mexican- American war is not more appropriate to the American revolution than it is to the Civil war considering it was a prelude to the ACW and many future ACW General fought in it. The actual tactics are closer to what happened in the beginning of the ACW. That is my view and is why I suggested it. Should we not take advantage of any games that could expand our club and make it stronger?
There are several questions here and I would like to be enlightened by your response.
I think that it would be interesting to understand the reasoning.
Since I proposed that the Mexican - American war be included in the club, my position is obviously clear, your position, which is an important indication of your Presidency is very important to understand. I think it would be of interest to the voters.