Napoleonic Wargame Club (NWC)

Am I not allowed a more complex viewpoint on the situation?? Just because I was a Prussian in the Club doesn't emulate everything I think about the Wars. The War wasn't won or loss by one specific force. Yes do I think very favorable of the Prussians, sure I do, probably more than others, but their story of overcoming a crushing defeat and setting up trends and systems that are still used to this day is a very far reaching impact.

Also in military studies, doing a comparative analysis of a component such as different commanders is key to the study of such a subject. It is a foundational root of military studies. What they did right, what they did wrong, what one can learn from them et al...

We all respect the Prussian reorganization. We all study the leaders, strategies, and tactics. We all have a solid background in military history. We are all academics to one degree or another. You are certainly entitled to your opinion, however "complex" you may deem it to be. Every member of our club is equally entitled to thier opinion. From my perspective, you are inconsistent. That is my opinion.

You were not just 'role playing' when you were in the Prussian Army. You fervently believed it. I know this about you beyond any shadow of doubt. A statement by you that the Russians were the best is inconsistent. It comes across to me as pandering, because I know it is not what you truly believe.