Colonial Campaigns Club (CCC)

Guys- I would like for you to chime in with your opinion! (I did read your post Mr. Sands [:)])

Scott Ludwig and I are in a tussle in FWI: Upper Kittanning scenario- Pa. Milita are raiding a Delaware village in the early morn. In Pregame Scott and I discussed rules and he preferred houserules with line melees. I stated that Indians meleed best from column, which I though matched a historical sense, and in a raid situation I thought his milita would be doing the same- rushing into the village, more or less on a speed attack- A helter/skelter affair. He choose to stay with club organization houserules but said I could use column melee if I wanted. I tried to remain in line throughout the game and had gained upper hand by outflanking and surrounding much of his position. The Indian small arms fire did little or no damage!! I had to melee to disrupt- I tried in line at first- no success!! The last few turns I turned to column and gained some victories! Whew . . . long winded, the POINT IS

What do you guys think:
INDIAN MELEES- only by line or is column ok!! [?][xx(]

Thank you for reading. [8D]